Home › Recipes › Desserts

Homemade Peanut Butter Cups

Snejana Andreeva - 1

By Snejana Andreeva

on Jun 25, 2021, Updated Sep 25, 2025

Add as a preferred source on Google - 2

My 4 ingredient Homemade Peanut Butter Cups are better than Reese’s! No more labels with a long list of test-tube 🧪 additives. My version of this nostalgic treat uses wholesome ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry. With just cocoa, coconut oil, peanut butter, and maple syrup, you can make these at home in just 20 minutes . Wrap them up in a pretty box to give as gifts 🎁 during the holidays or keep a stash in the kitchen for whenever your sweet tooth 🦷 hits.

Key Takeaways

  • My Homemade Peanut Butter Cups are simple and made with only 4 wholesome ingredients: cocoa, coconut oil, peanut butter, and maple syrup.

  • They take just 20 minutes to prepare and can be customized with toppings like sea salt or crushed nuts.

  • These cups are not only delicious but also healthier than store-bought options. You get to control the ingredients.

  • You can gift them in pretty boxes or enjoy them as a sweet treat anytime, and they freeze well for making ahead.

  • Variations include using different nut or seed butters, sweeteners, or shaping them into chocolate bark.

  • Key Takeaways

  • Why You’ll Love Peanut Butter Cups

  • Ingredients

  • Nonna’s Tip 🍫

  • Variations and Substitutions for Peanut Butter Cups

  • Similar Recipes

  • Best Served With

  • Common Questions

  • Homemade Peanut Butter Cups Recipe

  • More Chocolate Recipes

Why You’ll Love Peanut Butter Cups

Crispy and chocolatey 🍫 on the outside, creamy and sweet on the inside, my Homemade Peanut Butter Cups are a million times better than any packaged variety. The best part? You know exactly what ingredients are in them 🤓. Cocoa powder is packed with antioxidants and forms a crispy magic shell when mixed with coconut oil. Maple syrup adds natural sweetness, balancing out the bitterness of the raw cocoa. The star ⭐️ of the show, peanut butter forms the creamy center that keeps you craving more. You can make your cups as big or as small as you’d like and customize them with your favorite toppings – think flaky sea salt, crushed nuts, or shredded coconut 🥥 – for the perfect sweet treat.

Ingredients

🍫 Cocoa powder: When mixed with coconut oil, cocoa powder forms a magic shell that hardens as it cools.

🥜 Peanut butter: A spoonful of creamy peanut butter forms the iconic creamy center.

🥥 Coconut oil: This is the secret ingredient that turns your cocoa powder into a a crispy chocolate coating.

🍁 Maple syrup: Adding this to your cocoa mixture sweetens your peanut butter cups naturally without the need for refined sugars.

Nonna’s Tip 🍫

You can make these as big or as small as you’d like. You could even spread them flat on a baking sheet as a chocolate bark and break off chunks.

Homemade peanut butter cups topped with flaky sea salt - 3

Variations and Substitutions for Peanut Butter Cups

  1. A sprinkling of coarse 🧂 sea salt adds texture and cuts through the rich sweetness.
  2. You can use whatever nut butte r you love such as almond butter, cashew butter, or sunflower seed butter.
  3. For a pretty presentation , top your peanut butter cups with crushed nuts or shredded 🥥 coconut.
  4. Instead of maple syrup, use your preferred sweetener, such as agave nectar, stevia, 🍯 honey, or monkfruit.

Similar Recipes

A plate of chocolate truffles dusted with cocoa powder, some coated in chopped nuts, with a honey dipper resting on the plate and honey pooling beneath it. - 4 A plate of chocolate truffles dusted with cocoa powder, some coated in chopped nuts, with a honey dipper resting on the plate and honey pooling beneath it. - 5

No Bake Chocolate Balls

15 mins

A plate with several chocolate Energy Balls topped with chopped nuts, one bite revealing a dense, fudgy interior. Pieces of chocolate are scattered around the bites on white parchment paper. - 6 A plate with several chocolate Energy Balls topped with chopped nuts, one bite revealing a dense, fudgy interior. Pieces of chocolate are scattered around the bites on white parchment paper. - 7

Energy Balls

10 mins

A hand holds up a chocolate-covered dessert with a bite taken, revealing a caramel or nougat-like filling. More of these treats are piled on a white plate in the background, all on a brown table surface. - 8 A hand holds up a chocolate-covered dessert with a bite taken, revealing a caramel or nougat-like filling. More of these treats are piled on a white plate in the background, all on a brown table surface. - 9

3 Ingredient Peanut Butter Balls

20 mins

A close-up of Healthy Chocolate Turtles—chocolate-covered candies with a caramel and nut filling, topped with pecans and a sprinkle of sea salt, beautifully arranged on a white plate. - 10 A close-up of Healthy Chocolate Turtles—chocolate-covered candies with a caramel and nut filling, topped with pecans and a sprinkle of sea salt, beautifully arranged on a white plate. - 11

Healthy Chocolate Turtles

30 mins

Best Served With

  • A cup of ☕ coffee or tea as an afternoon pick-me-up.
  • Break up a Peanut Butter Cup and serve it over a bowl of ice cream .
  • Nestle a few Peanut Butter Cups in a 🥝 fruit tray as a sweet treat.
  • You could absolutely package up a few of the Peanut Butter Cups in a small box, tin or cookie bag and present this as a 🎁 homemade gift for a holiday.

Common Questions

No, coconut oil is essential for this recipe as it solidifies when chilled, giving the peanut butter cups their firm texture. I haven’t tried with another type of oil, but I don’t think it would be as successful.

Instead of maple syrup, use your preferred sweetener, such as agave nectar, stevia, honey or monk fruit.

I used peanut butter here, but you could certainly use almond butter, cashew butter, or sunflower seed butter.

You can use silicone molds or small baking cups as an alternative to muffin liners.

Of course! Additionally, you can sprinkle sea salt, crushed nuts, or shredded coconut on top before refrigerating for added texture and flavor.

Absolutely! Allow them to cool completely and then transfer to a freezer bag or container. Freeze for up to 2 months.

A New Recipe Card!!

  1. Check off each step in instructions!
  2. Add ingredients to your shopping list!

Equipment

  • ▢ Medium Pot
  • ▢ Liquid Measuring Cup
  • ▢ Measuring Cups + Spoons
  • ▢ Silicone Muffin Pan

Ingredients

  • ▢ ½ cup coconut oil , no substitute
  • ▢ ⅓ cup maple syrup
  • ▢ ¼ cup unsweetened cocoa , or cacao powder
  • ▢ 11 teaspoons peanut butter , or any nut or seed butter

Instructions

  • ▢ In a pot over low heat, melt the coconut oil.
  • ▢ Take it off the heat as soon as it melts and add the cacao and maple syrup. Whisk well.
  • ▢ Take 11 muffin liners and add 2 teaspoons of your chocolate, followed by 1 teaspoon of any nut or seed butter and top them off with another two teaspoons of chocolate.
  • ▢ Store them in the fridge and enjoy.

Nonna’s Notes

  • Salty+sweet: A sprinkling of coarse sea salt adds texture and cuts through the rich sweetness.
  • Nut butters: You can use whatever nut butter you love such as almond butter, cashew butter, or sunflower seed butter.
  • Toppings: For a pretty presentation, top your peanut butter cups with crushed nuts or shredded coconut.
  • Sweeteners: Instead of maple syrup, use your preferred sweetener, such as agave nectar, stevia, honey, or monkfruit.

My Notes

Nutrition

Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.

More Chocolate Recipes

A plate of chocolate-covered dates sprinkled with crushed nuts and colorful toppings. One of the dates is cut open, revealing a green filling. The plate is on a light wooden surface. - 12 A plate of chocolate-covered dates sprinkled with crushed nuts and colorful toppings. One of the dates is cut open, revealing a green filling. The plate is on a light wooden surface. - 13

Dubai Chocolate Dates

1 hr 3 mins

A close-up of a piece of chocolate with a unique, angular top design. It is topped with small bits of crushed nuts, and the center reveals a green, textured filling on a wooden surface. - 14 A close-up of a piece of chocolate with a unique, angular top design. It is topped with small bits of crushed nuts, and the center reveals a green, textured filling on a wooden surface. - 15

Dubai Chocolate Bar

1 hr 20 mins

A ceramic plate filled with Bounty Dates—chocolate-covered treats, some whole and others cut open to reveal a white and caramel-colored filling—topped with flakes of sea salt. - 16 A ceramic plate filled with Bounty Dates—chocolate-covered treats, some whole and others cut open to reveal a white and caramel-colored filling—topped with flakes of sea salt. - 17

Bounty Dates

15 mins

A plate of Chocolate Covered Dates, some cut open to reveal a creamy peanut butter filling, sprinkled with bits of sea salt and crunchy nuts. - 18 A plate of Chocolate Covered Dates, some cut open to reveal a creamy peanut butter filling, sprinkled with bits of sea salt and crunchy nuts. - 19

Chocolate Covered Dates

40 mins

Homemade Peanut Butter Cups

Equipment

  • Medium Pot
  • Liquid Measuring Cup
  • Measuring Cups + Spoons
  • Silicone Muffin Pan

Ingredients

  • ½ cup coconut oil no substitute
  • ⅓ cup maple syrup
  • ¼ cup unsweetened cocoa or cacao powder
  • 11 teaspoons peanut butter or any nut or seed butter

Instructions

  • In a pot over low heat, melt the coconut oil.
  • Take it off the heat as soon as it melts and add the cacao and maple syrup. Whisk well.
  • Take 11 muffin liners and add 2 teaspoons of your chocolate, followed by 1 teaspoon of any nut or seed butter and top them off with another two teaspoons of chocolate.
  • Store them in the fridge and enjoy.

Notes

  • Salty+sweet: A sprinkling of coarse sea salt adds texture and cuts through the rich sweetness.
  • Nut butters: You can use whatever nut butter you love such as almond butter, cashew butter, or sunflower seed butter.
  • Toppings: For a pretty presentation, top your peanut butter cups with crushed nuts or shredded coconut.
  • Sweeteners: Instead of maple syrup, use your preferred sweetener, such as agave nectar, stevia, honey, or monkfruit.

Nutrition

Homemade Peanut Butter Cups https://themodernnonna.com/homemade-peanut-butter-cups/ June 25, 2021